Bengals' Defensive Dilemma: Slim Odds for Hendrickson and Stewart at Training Camp Opening
As the Cincinnati Bengals gear up for their 2025 training camp, a significant cloud of uncertainty hangs over their defensive line. The highly anticipated presence of star defensive end Trey Hendrickson and promising rookie Shemar Stewart at the opening of practices appears increasingly unlikely. This dual absence, stemming from contrasting but equally impactful contract disputes, poses a critical challenge for a Bengals defense looking to make a statement in a competitive AFC North.
Trey Hendrickson: A Veteran's Value and Contract Standoff
Trey Hendrickson, an All-Pro selection who led the NFL with 17.5 sacks last season, is entering the final year of his current NFL contract and is reportedly seeking a long-term extension that reflects his elite production. Despite being a cornerstone of the Bengals' defensive success since his arrival in 2021, the team and Hendrickson's representatives have reached an impasse over guaranteed money.
Hendrickson has made it clear he won't play the 2025 season under his current terms, having previously requested a trade earlier this offseason. His decision not to report to camp with the veteran players underscores his resolve. While the Bengals have successfully secured lucrative contracts for other key players like Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins, the situation with Hendrickson is proving to be a tougher negotiation. The team's owner, Mike Brown, expressed hope for a swift resolution but remained tight-lipped on the specifics, indicating the delicate nature of the financial investment at stake.
The absence of a proven pass rusher of Hendrickson's caliber could significantly impact the Bengals' defensive strategy. His consistent ability to pressure opposing quarterbacks is invaluable, and finding a suitable replacement or managing without him will be a major test for the coaching staff.
Shemar Stewart: Rookie Holdout and Contract Language Quandary
On the other side of the spectrum is Shemar Stewart, the Bengals' 17th overall pick in the recent NFL Draft. Unlike Hendrickson's pursuit of an extension, Stewart's absence is due to an unprecedented holdout over rookie contract language. While rookie deals are typically slotted and straightforward, the Bengals are reportedly attempting to include provisions that could void future guarantees in the event of off-field incidents.
This has created a deadlock between Stewart's agent, Zac Hiller, and the Bengals' front office. Stewart is the only first-round pick from his draft class who remains unsigned, a rare occurrence that highlights the contentious nature of this legal dispute. Bengals director of player personnel Duke Tobin emphasized the team's desire to "evolve" and align with standard league practices, but Stewart's camp is resisting, arguing against being the guinea pig for new contract precedents.
For a rookie, missing training camp practices is particularly detrimental. Stewart is expected to contribute immediately to a Bengals defense that finished 25th in total defense last season. Every day he misses is a lost opportunity to learn the playbook, build chemistry with teammates, and adapt to the professional football environment. Quarterback Joe Burrow has publicly voiced his disappointment, emphasizing the critical need for a full defensive roster.
The Impact on the Bengals' 2025 Season
The dual holdouts create a significant challenge for the Bengals as they aim to return to the playoffs and compete for a Super Bowl. Without their top pass rusher and a highly touted rookie defensive end, the depth and effectiveness of their defensive line are severely compromised.
The current defensive end depth chart, featuring players like B.J. Hill, Myles Murphy, Cam Sample, and Joseph Ossai, will be under increased scrutiny. While these players possess talent, they face immense pressure to step up and fill the void left by Hendrickson and Stewart. The team's ability to optimize performance on defense will hinge on finding quick resolutions to these contract impasses.
Fans and sports betting enthusiasts are closely watching the situation, as the outcome of these negotiations could directly influence the Bengals' championship odds. The clock is ticking, and the urgency to get both players on the field is growing with each passing day of training camp. The Bengals' front office faces a critical decision: meet the demands of their stars, or risk a significant blow to their competitive advantage in the upcoming season.
